Makita XDT16Z vs DeWalt DCF887: Impact Drivers Compared
FriendsWithTools.io earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. We do not test these tools ourselves — all claims are sourced from manufacturer specifications, retailer listings, and aggregated user reviews, each linked inline. Prices and ratings were verified on April 2026 and may have changed.
The Makita XDT16Z and DeWalt DCF887 sit in the same tier: brushless, multi-speed, sub-$150 bare tool impact drivers that handle everything from cabinet screws to structural lag bolts. The Makita brings Quick-Shift Mode for fastener control. The DeWalt counters with Precision Drive. Both try to solve the same problem: stopping the driver before it buries a screw too deep or snaps a fastener head.
Quick Verdict
The DeWalt DCF887 delivers more torque for $20 less. For general construction and remodeling, it's the better value. The Makita XDT16Z is the better tool for tight-space work and precision fastening. The shorter body and Quick-Shift Mode give it an edge in cabinet installation and finish carpentry where access and screw control matter more than raw torque.
1,825 in-lbs of torque at $119 is the best performance per dollar in this comparison.
Quick-Shift Mode and the 4-5/8 inch body length prevent stripped screws and fit inside face-frame cabinets.
Same batteries across 275+ LXT tools. No sense starting a second battery collection.
225 more in-lbs of torque means less stalling on 3/8-inch lags in treated lumber.
Specs at a Glance
| Spec | Makita XDT16Z | DeWalt DCF887 |
|---|---|---|
| Max Torque | 1,600 in-lbs | 1,825 in-lbs |
| No-Load Speed | 0 to 3,600 RPM | 0 to 3,250 RPM |
| Impact Rate | 0 to 3,800 IPM | 0 to 3,600 IPM |
| Chuck Size | 1/4 in hex | 1/4 in hex |
| Battery Platform | 18V LXT | 20V MAX |
| Weight (bare) | 2.0 lb (bare) | 2.0 lb (bare) |
| Speed Settings | 4-speed + Quick-Shift Mode | 3-speed + Precision Drive |
| Head Length | 4-5/8 in | 5.3 in |
Makita XDT16Z
Price: $139 (Amazon)
Pros
- Quick-Shift Mode reduces rotation speed right after impact engagement, preventing cam-outs and stripped heads
- 4-5/8 inch body length fits in tight joist pockets and electrical boxes
- 2.0 lb bare is among the lightest impact drivers at this performance level
Cons
- 1,600 in-lbs is adequate but trails Milwaukee and some DeWalt models on raw torque
- Tightening mode (Quick-Shift) takes practice to understand when it activates
- LXT batteries charge slower than competing rapid-charge systems
DeWalt DCF887
Price: $119 (Home Depot)
Pros
- 1,825 in-lbs of torque handles heavier fasteners than the Makita without stalling
- Precision Drive on speed 1 gives controlled starts for delicate cabinetry screws
- $20 cheaper bare tool than the Makita
Cons
- 5.3 inches is 3/4 inch longer than the Makita, which matters in tight spots
- 3 speeds vs 4 gives you one fewer torque option
- Plastic belt clip is prone to breaking if it catches on framing
Best For
General construction and remodeling
DeWalt DCF887
1,825 in-lbs of torque at $119 is the best performance per dollar in this comparison.
Cabinet installation and finish work
Makita XDT16Z
Quick-Shift Mode and the 4-5/8 inch body length prevent stripped screws and fit inside face-frame cabinets.
Already invested in LXT batteries
Makita XDT16Z
Same batteries across 275+ LXT tools. No sense starting a second battery collection.
Driving structural lag bolts
DeWalt DCF887
225 more in-lbs of torque means less stalling on 3/8-inch lags in treated lumber.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between Quick-Shift Mode and Precision Drive?
Both try to prevent overdriving. Quick-Shift Mode (Makita) automatically reduces rotation speed the moment the impact mechanism engages, so the fastener seats without the driver spinning out of control. Precision Drive (DeWalt) limits speed on the first setting for controlled starts. Quick-Shift works at any speed. Precision Drive only works on speed 1.
Can I use Makita blades and bits in the DeWalt, and vice versa?
Both accept standard 1/4-inch hex shank bits. Any brand of impact-rated bit works in either driver. Don't cheap out on bits though; non-impact-rated bits shatter under the hammering.
Is 1,600 in-lbs enough torque?
For 95% of fasteners you'll encounter in residential construction, yes. 1,600 in-lbs drives 4-inch structural screws, GRK cabinet screws, and lag bolts up to 5/16 inch without issues. You'd only notice the difference on 3/8-inch lags in dense hardwood.