DeWalt DCS367B vs Milwaukee 2719-20: Compact Reciprocating Saws Compared
FriendsWithTools.io earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page, at no additional cost to you. We do not test these tools ourselves — all claims are sourced from manufacturer specifications, retailer listings, and aggregated user reviews, each linked inline. Prices and ratings were verified on April 2026 and may have changed.
Full-size reciprocating saws are great for demolition, but they're too big for plumbing cuts in a wall cavity or PVC work overhead. These compact recip saws weigh under 5 lb, fit in tight spaces, and still cut through 2x4s and copper pipe. The DeWalt DCS367B is the longer-stroke option. The Milwaukee 2719-20 (HACKZALL) is the true one-handed saw. Different tools for different access situations.
Quick Verdict
These are genuinely different tools. The DeWalt DCS367B is a compact reciprocating saw that happens to be small. The Milwaukee 2719-20 is a one-handed cutting tool designed for plumbing and electrical work. If you cut a mix of wood and pipe in renovation work, the DeWalt's longer stroke and orbital action win. If you spend most of your time cutting copper, PVC, and threaded rod in tight spots, the HACKZALL is the right tool.
One-handed operation in wall cavities and ceiling bays where a two-handed saw can't fit.
Orbital action and longer stroke cut through nail-embedded lumber twice as fast.
3.4 lb bare is light enough to hold overhead with one hand while supporting conduit with the other.
Specs at a Glance
| Spec | DeWalt DCS367B | Milwaukee 2719-20 |
|---|---|---|
| Stroke Length | 1-1/8 in | 7/8 in |
| Strokes Per Minute | 0 to 2,900 SPM | 0 to 3,000 SPM |
| Blade Clamp | Keyless, 4-position | QUIK-LOK, tool-free |
| Battery Platform | 20V MAX | 18V (M18) |
| Weight (bare) | 4.5 lb (bare) | 3.4 lb (bare) |
| Orbital Action | Yes | No |
| LED Work Light | Yes | Yes |
DeWalt DCS367B
Price: $149 (Home Depot)
Pros
- 1-1/8 inch stroke is the longest in the compact class, cuts faster in thick material
- 4-position blade clamp lets you rotate the blade for flush cuts against floors and ceilings
- Orbital action toggle speeds up wood cutting when you don't need a clean edge
Cons
- 4.5 lb is heavier than the Milwaukee, noticeable during extended overhead work
- Orbital action adds vibration that makes metal cuts rougher
- Profile is wider than the HACKZALL, limiting access in narrow wall bays
Milwaukee 2719-20
Price: $129 (Home Depot)
Pros
- 3.4 lb bare weight is light enough for genuine one-handed overhead cuts
- Compact head fits into spaces where the DeWalt physically cannot reach
- $20 cheaper and runs on the massive M18 battery ecosystem
Cons
- 7/8 inch stroke is noticeably slower through 2x4s and thick PVC
- No orbital action means wood cutting is always slower than the DeWalt
- Vibrates more in the hand because the shorter stroke cycles faster
Best For
Plumbing rough-in (copper and PVC)
Milwaukee 2719-20
One-handed operation in wall cavities and ceiling bays where a two-handed saw can't fit.
Remodeling demolition (studs and nails)
DeWalt DCS367B
Orbital action and longer stroke cut through nail-embedded lumber twice as fast.
Overhead electrical work
Milwaukee 2719-20
3.4 lb bare is light enough to hold overhead with one hand while supporting conduit with the other.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use full-length recip saw blades in these?
Physically yes, both accept standard reciprocating saw blades. Practically, a 12-inch blade on a compact saw is unwieldy and the short stroke wastes most of the blade length. Stick with 4 to 6-inch blades for best performance.
Is a compact recip saw enough to replace a full-size one?
For remodeling and service work, usually yes. For heavy demolition (ripping out framing, cutting cast iron pipe), no. The full-size saws have 50 to 100% longer strokes and significantly more power under sustained load.